"Great Agency! Shopped me with 32 different A+ rated national insurance carriers to get me the best price. My previous local insurance broker quoted me a best price of $1526 so I decided to shop around. I walked out of Bagnall Shaw with better coverage and a Travelers Insurance policy for $912! Best Move Ever!! Nice staff as well."
- Todd A.
"Back in October 2015, I was in a car accident. Both cars were totaled and I was extremely shaken from the experience. Immediately, I contacted Bagnall Shaw and they assisted me in getting my claim submitted that same evening. Erie Insurance provided me with detailed instructions and helped get a rental car for me to drive for work the very next morning. I was given an SUV upgrade based on the relationship Safeco has with Enterprise and the process was hassle free.
It has been a few months and I received some communications from the other driver's insurance. I provided the documentation to my agent at Bagnall Shaw asking for her assistance. She explained the process and even submitted the documents to Safeco Insurance on my behalf. In less than 24 hours, she sent email confirmation that the matter is being taken care of.
I switched my homeowners, small business and car insurance only last year and I am already confident in my decision knowing that Bagnall Shaw and Safeco Insurance have got me covered.
Finding a trustworthy and reliable insurance company can be a real challenge. I am confident that Bagnall Shaw and my Insurance have my back. Thank you for giving me peace of mind!
- Nadine M.
"Like how organized everything is"
- Josue A.
"Excellent customer service and great quotes for many products!!"
- Lizzette C.
"I went there on Friday and even though I had to wait 15 minutes (always a very busy place but worth it), they took care of all my needs and were very helpful explaining to how insurance works. They saved me a ton of money and gave me more coverage with Main Street America Insurance than I had before. Great place!"
- loan l.
"Great customer service and they offer great insurance rates! Highly recommend!"
- Amy S.