Welcome to Bagnall Shaw Insurance


​"We Shop! You Save!"

Downtown Lancaster's #1 Independent Full-Service Insurance Broker!
​Serving All of Pennsylvania & Connecticut. Your Trusted Choice Since 2008. 

​We Shop Over 50 of The Best Insurance Carriers in America - Free & All at Once For You!
Our New Customers Save An Average of Over $500 When Switching to Us.

Always Free Quotes!   Never Any Agency or Broker Fees!
"​Cut Your Costs, Not Your Coverage."

LOWEST RATES FROM EVERY CARRIER SOLD!!

​​Hablamos Español.  La Agencia de Habla Hispana Más Grande del Centro de Pensilvania. 

Our top priority has always been helping people!! All of our clients save money.  All our business clients reduce their risk.  All our families protect and preserve their financial future.

We also offer Business Formation Services from our trained experts.
​
INSURANCE NEWS HEADLINES
​Maryland State Insurance Administration investigating "Erie Insurance" for alleged ​illegal discriminatory practices​ against low-income and minority communities.  Complaint also reveals that "Erie Insurance" previously paid $225,000 to settle a Federal Lawsuit for illegally discriminating against African-American customers. (1/21/2021)​

​Pennsylvania Judge orders major class-action lawsuit against "Erie Insurance" to move forward for allegedly refusing to pay valid insurance claims. (7/23/2020)

​​​​
​Notice To Our Valued Bagnall Shaw Customers:
​
We are very proud to announce that we no longer contract with "Erie Insurance".  Based on the news headlines above, Erie clearly does not share our moral and ethical values.  Bagnall Shaw Insurance believes in service to ALL customers (regardless of race, ethnicity, or zip code) and that legitimate claims should be paid (without class-action lawsuits required).  

​Due to our “Erie Insurance” partnership ending, we cannot access or service any Erie policy renewals occurring after February 24th, 2021.  Most of our Erie clients have already cancelled their Erie policies & moved to our 50 respective carriers (while saving money).  If you have not moved from “Erie Insurance”, please contact us immediately.
​
​How can we help you today?

COVID-19 Statement

The Downtown West Orange Street Office is Open to the public.

Client Facemasks Required

Client Service Also Always Available by Phone, Email, Online & Directly Through Most Carriers.
​
We wish for everyone to stay healthy & safe during this pandemic.
​We appreciate your continued business and thank you for your support!!

WHY CHOOSE A ​
​LOCAL INDEPENDENT
INSURANCE AGENCY?
  • We provide FREE QUOTES FROM UP TO 50 COMPANIES in 20 minutes or less!
  • Our average new customer Saves Over 25% by shopping insurance with us! 
  • SAVE TIME!  One quick visit gets you all available quotes at once to compare.
  • SAVE MONEY!  If rates go up you are never "stuck" with your carrier.
  • ALWAYS THE LOWEST PRICE! Our quotes are the same prices as you calling each carrier. 
  • ALWAYS FREE GUARANTEE! We never charge any fees to you for our insurance services.  
  • Speak to an experienced insurance advisor every time you call.
  • Always get personalized coverage recommendations from your agent.
  • Our loyalty is only to YOU and YOUR best interests, and never just one insurance carrier like Erie, Geico, Farmers, Allstate and State Farm Agents are required to do at your expense!!
  • EXCLUSIVE CARRIER MULTIPLE DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE! These include Exclusive Competition Price-Match Offers, AAA, Sam's Club, Costco, Teacher, First-Responder, Student, Home Owner, Safe Driver, Safe Home, Multi-Policy, Automatic Payment, Claims-Free Cashback & many more!!
  • Need help with a claim? We are always here to assist you!​

 Get an Instant Free Insurance Quote Online Now!

Need Both an Auto and Home Insurance Quote Right Now?

You'll immediately receive a personal, real-time quote from our ​A+ ranked insurance carriers.  24 hours a day / 7 days a week!   Free with no obligation!
​
​Many additional carrier quotes available directly from our licensed agents once submitted

About Our Agency

Se Habla Español
Since 2008, Bagnall Shaw's goal has been to guarantee that our local Lancaster, as well as our statewide Pennsylvania & Connecticut repeat clients have the right coverage at the absolute lowest price anywhere.  We only partner with the most highly respected, consumer-friendly carriers in our industry. Imagine having a broker that ignores commissions and commits their focus to finding you the best insurance coverage that you can afford. 

Using our exclusive, modern technology; We offer LIVE, REAL-TIME FREE QUOTES from ​up to ​50 A and A+ Rated Insurance Carriers at once for you to compare and shop for free with absolutely no obligation! 

​Our exclusive ​20 Minute Super Saver Multi-Quote saves the average new client 30% off their home and auto premium when written together!

90% of our clients return year after year because our service and prices are unbeatable!

It's time for you to discover the "Bagnall Shaw Difference" and SAVE BIG with us too!!

DOWNTOWN LANCASTER'S LARGEST, INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENCY.  FASTEST GROWING DOWNTOWN INSURANCE BROKERAGE SINCE 2008!

Online Service​

Our website is a resource to clients. Visit our online service center to find out all the ways this website can help you.

Learn More About Insurance

When it comes to insurance, we've got you covered. Learn more about how our products can help you.

Contact Us Today
Phone: (717) 431-8383​
Fax: (717) 431-8383​
Email: info@bagnallshaw.com

Mailing Address:
401 W. Orange Street
Lancaster, PA 17603​

Agency Hours:
Monday - Friday: 9:30am - 6:00pm

We are honored to represent highly respected insurance carriers like: